The Journal of Geoethics and Social Geoscience published a new open access article on 13 December 2024.
We remind you that this journal is diamond open access and is supported by the IAPG, the IUGS Commission on Geoethics and the CIPSH Chair on Geoethics. No Article Processing Charge (APC) is requested to authors and no fee to readers.
The new article can be cited as follows:
Cleverley P.H. (2024). Ethical recommendations for Artificial Intelligence technology in the Geological Sciences - with a focus on Language Models. Journal of Geoethics and Social Geosciences, 1(2), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.13127/jgsg-63
Abstract:
Artificial Intelligence (AI) offers many opportunities for the geosciences to improve productivity, reduce uncertainty in models and stimulate discovery of new knowledge. There are also risks to geoscience, from the spread of obsolete, inaccurate and misinformation, to threats on fundamental human rights.
Whilst ethical AI frameworks exist from numerous institutions such as UNESCO, they are high level and lack practical detail in the geosciences particularly for Large Language Models (LLM). This is evidenced by the misalignment between the way current geoscience AI/LLMs are being designed, trained and deployed, with core ethical principles.
Using principles and frameworks from UNESCO and the International Science Council (ISC), a set of ten recommendations are proposed to bridge the gap between practice and these ethical frameworks. Critical Realism is used as an underlying philosophy which allows the potential to provide justifiable recommendations to ethical and moral questions using judgemental rationality.
These recommendations may help stakeholders in the international community reach conclusions on what ‘good looks like’ for ethical AI in the geological sciences focusing on Language Models and their applications. This may inform developers, regulators, policy advisors, journal editors, geological surveys, societies, institutions and unions, publishers, funding bodies, geoscientists and decision makers.
This is believed to be the first research paper on AI ethics in the geological sciences with a focus on Generative AI. Understanding the nuances of our ethical choices for both the development and use of LLMs and other AI tools in the geosciences, has the potential to positively impact science integrity, and critically, ensure fairness, personal privacy, democratic norms and human rights are safeguarded.
Keywords:
Geoethics, ethics, artificial intelligence, geology, large language models, earth science, geosciences
Free download:
The author: Paul H. Cleverley, Visiting Professor of Information Science and Technology, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, Scotland, United Kingdom.
Geologist and Computer Scientist by background. He has spent over 30 years working at the interface of these two disciplines in Digital Geoscience, in both academia and industry, and within the UK and Internationally. He has received the UK's highest Business Award for Outstanding Innovation twice as an entrepreneur, for tech companies he has owned / founded in digital geoscience. His free blog on digital geoscience founded in 2015 is read world-wide in over 140 countries. He has a number of voluntary roles, including serving on the governance committee of the nonprofit cooperative GeoScienceWorld, advising the British Geological Survey on Natural Language Processing and as a Digital Champion for Age UK, helping to improve digital inclusion and literacy for older adults. He was recently appointed as Chair of the AI Ethics Task Group of the Geoethics Commission of the International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS).
Journal of Geoethics and Social Geosciences:
Articles published in the Journal of Geoethics and Social Geosciences:
IAPG - International Association for Promoting Geoethics:
IUGS - Commission on Geoethics:
CIPSH - Chair on Geoethics:
Comments